What to Know About the Leaked Supreme Court Abortion Draft Opinion, and What’s Next
[….]
Roughly half of the states will ban abortion almost immediately, and half the states will continue to allow abortion. But it’s important to understand that the long-term agenda of abortion opponents doesn’t end with overturning Roe. What they want is a nationwide ban on abortion. So if you’re in a state like New York or California, where you believe you will have access to abortion even if Roe is overturned, that is true in the short term. But the plan from abortion opponents is to continue to push for a nationwide ban, so that could change.
[….]
May 8, 2022 – abortion rights rally in Kansas City:
“They fucking lied…”
“…and I’m fucking pissed”
A half century of women’s right to privacy, bodily autonomy, and health care agency are gone.
Missouri’s junior senator, Republican Roy Blunt, has finally deigned to give us, via the GOP House organ, Fox News, his version of their Kavanaugh talking points:
The key comments here are his claims that “unfair” and “unrealistic” Democrats sat on Dr. Blasey-Ford’s story until late in the process and then declared Kavanaugh “guilty until proven innocent.” Since Fox’s Maria Bartiromo didn’t seem to want to push back on these assertions, I would like to offer the following observations:
— Although evidence indicates that Senator Dianne Feinstein’s account of the reasons for the late timing is accurate, the entire question amounts to little more than a red herring. The real issue is whether credible claims of serious wrong-doing should be ignored and not be fully investigated because they didn’t emerge earlier during more general routine vetting; innocent until proven guilty presupposes that a fair and transparent effort to secure proof will take place.
— One might also note that whether or not Kavanaugh is, as Senator Blunt asserts, one of the “most vetted candidate in the history of confirmations” is not a real answer to credible claims by his Democratic colleagues that the very curtailed and limited investigation into this specific allegation was inadequate.
Sen. Blunt is to be commended for not picking up on the shameless GOP whine about how Blasey-Ford’s credible accusations endanger those poor, quivering, white males who might be falsely accused of sexual assault. Yes, false accusations of rape are made – in, it is estimated, only 2 – 10% of cases. It follows that that 90%+ rape allegations are verified. And, of course, the way to verify the truth of any allegation of sexual assault is a full and unbiased investigation of the sort that the GOP-controlled senate and the White House did not allow to take place in the Kavanaugh case. Wonder why, anyone?
Finally, Blunt, riding high on the results of a Marist poll from last week, that found GOP enthusiasm for voting heightened after the Kavanaugh hearings, predicts that if Democrats continue to raise issues about the legitimacy of Kavanaugh’s appointment, the “strategy” will backfire. In other words, the GOP wants to put down a potential on-going firestorm before it blows their narrative out of the water – and they’re counting on past Democratic spinelessness in the face of conservative attacks to do the job.
However, today a CNN poll which, unlike the Marist poll, was taken after the confirmation of Kavanaugh, should give Senator Blunt pause when it comes to trying to scare Democrats out of demonstrating their anger about a stolen Supreme Court appointment: in response to a question about voting enthusiasm, 62% of Democrats say they are “extremely or very enthusiastic to vote, up seven points since September.” In contrast, 52% of Republicans reported enthusiasm about voting in November, a result that is only 2% higher than in September.
Maybe Senator Blunt ought to help his senate leadership cronies retool some of that nasty, Trumpian Kavanaugh spin they’re spewing. It’s possible that even a few Republicans are embarrassed to belong to a party that elevates misogynistic, biased, lying, judicial hacks to positions of power and prominence.
Yesterday evening, from Representative Vicky Hartzler (r):
Rep. Vicky Hartzler @RepHartzler
The Senate has done its due diligence in investigating Judge Kavanaugh, and they have found no evidence against him. Furthermore, this was turned into an embarrassing display of partisan vitriol. I support his confirmation and am pleased the Senate has acted accordingly. 4:03 PM – 6 Oct 2018 from Washington, DC
Some of the responses:
Weird how you were silent while the same Senate ignored the lawful nomination of Merrick Garland. Kind of like how you were silent while Trump was caging children and tearing families apart.
You make astonishingly immoral decisions, Congresswoman.
I cannot wait to vote for your opponent, and I’m hoping and praying there are many more like me that are disgusted with the GOP’s gross misuse of power. I voted you in to office, but you have proven that to be a mistake. #VoteBlue
My 3 week old could do a more thorough investigation than the FBI
Care to tell us why money was borrowed from China for your farm bill?
Incomplete investigation.
Get out and vote!
Your opinion won’t matter after you are voted out. Hope you enjoyed your time
I hope she didn’t enjoy it.
And won’t enjoy it after, when she’s scorned for life for being complicit in the criminal corrupt Trump regime.
You sold out your soul to the Republicans and now you are trying to invoke the moral high ground? Women like you make me feel ashamed of my own gender.
I am your constituent, living in MO-04, You will be voted out on Nov 6th, SHAME on you for taking side of sexual predator.
Vicky, here’s hoping we get an actual investigation of Kavanaugh once congressional control changes. The man I saw freaking out on television should not be making such momentous decisions.
“Due diligence in investigating”? “Found no evidence”? You haven’t been paying attention, Vickster [….]
Oh shut it. This investigation is a sham and you are a smear on America
BULLSHIT!
“embarrassing display of partisan vitriol” You Say
This is so very much nicer then shit show.
But then I’v never been accused of being overly nice when reacting to an obvious shit show…
Fuck you!
That’s probably a vote against in November.
The GOP party of Vicky Hartzler, Roy pedophile Moore. Donald pussy grabber Trump. Gym I watched boys getting molested Jordan and now Brett sexual predator Kavanaugh. You hang with some great people Vicky.
Steve Schmidt @SteveSchmidtSES
The price of Brett Kavanaugh’s ascension to the the SC is incalculably high. It will shatter the institutional integrity of the Court and eviscerate standards and expectations for both honesty and non partisanship in Judicial nominees for many years. 3:10 PM – 5 Oct 2018
That horse left the barn a long, long time ago.
In 2000:
Stevens, J., dissenting
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
No. 00—949
GEORGE W. BUSH, et al., PETITIONERS v.
ALBERT GORE, Jr., et al.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE FLORIDA SUPREME COURT
[December 12, 2000]
Justice Stevens, with whom Justice Ginsburg and Justice Breyer join, dissenting.
[….]
…It is confidence in the men and women who administer the judicial system that is the true backbone of the rule of law. Time will one day heal the wound to that confidence that will be inflicted by today’s decision. One thing, however, is certain. Although we may never know with complete certainty the identity of the winner of this year’s Presidential election, the identity of the loser is perfectly clear. It is the Nation’s confidence in the judge as an impartial guardian of the rule of law…
From Molly Ivins’ forward to Vincent Bugiosi’s The Betrayal of America (2001):
…One forgets about small Southern cities like Tallahassee between visits. All middle-class social life takes place in private clubs. The night Al Gore conceded, there was a victory celebration at one such club near the capitol. Visiting congressional staffers (who proudly called themselves “the Republican thugs”), third-rank Bush lawyers, and prominent local republicans were gathered in a large room with several TV sets. When Gore began to speak, they hooted and jeered and taunted. The only black people in the room were wearing white coats and serving drinks off silver trays. They also had tears running down their faces, but in the curious way white people have of not looking directly at those who serve them, no one noticed.
“…[T]hird-rank Bush lawyers…” We’ve come full circle.
Never bet on Susan Collins (r) being anything other than a right wingnut republican.
Michael Bersin @MBersin
Once again, as always, the fervent old media belief in the existence of the “moderate republican” is a demonstrable myth. 3:14 PM – 5 Oct 2018
The U.S. Supreme Court as a respected institution is now lost to us for at least the next three decades.
Apparently being “over prepared” for a presidential debate is more disqualifying for ascendance to a high public office.
The U.S. Senate cloture vote on the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh to the U.S. Supreme Court will take place this morning.
Also, this morning:
L.A. Kauffman @LAKauffman
“What do we do with a drunken justice?” Protesters stage Kavanaugh confirmation kegger outside Mitch McConnell’s home in advance of cloture vote #StopKavanaugh #CANCELKAVANAUGH
[….] 6:59 AM – 5 Oct 2018
Donald J. Trump @realDonaldTrump
Wow! Just starting to hear the Democrats, who are only thinking Obstruct and Delay, are starting to put out the word that the “time” and “scope” of FBI looking into Judge Kavanaugh and witnesses is not enough. Hello! For them, it will never be enough – stay tuned and watch! 1:56 PM – 30 Sep 2018
“Fair is foul, and foul is fair:
Hover through the fog and filthy air…”