• About
  • The Poetry of Protest

Show Me Progress

~ covering government and politics in Missouri – since 2007

Show Me Progress

Tag Archives: health care

Rep. Emanuel Cleaver (D): on the Supreme Court ruling on the Affordable Care Act

28 Thursday Jun 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Affordable Care Act, Emanuel Cleaver, health care, missouri, Supreme Court

Representative Emanuel Cleaver (D) released a video on the Supreme Court decision:

Representative Emanuel Cleaver (D): This is certainly a historic day in this country, but not, but not a day to deepen our divisions or throw up our hands and celebrate and say our work is done. For all Americans, Republicans, Democrats, the states and the federal government must continue to work together to make sure healthcare is functional, full, and fair. Because of healthcare, millions and millions of seniors like my ninety year old father are getting free preventive services, children are not being denied coverage, and young adults are covered under their parents’ plan. These are big and important differences helping millions of Americans focus on their jobs and quality of life instead of worrying about what will happen if they and their family members get injured or sick. I know there are many who disagree with this decision. I hear from you. I know that there are many of you, but I pledge to work with and listen to any and everyone who calls. You need information about this unprecedented plan to insure all Americans. And so, if you have questions please don’t hesitate to call my office. I look forward to hearing from you. This is, I repeat, a truly historic day.

Gov. Jay Nixon at Missouri Boys State 2012: "I just assumed you were a Democrat…"

28 Thursday Jun 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

2012, Boys State, governor, health care, Jay Nixon, missouri

Previously: Ask Nixon about Medicare for All (June 27, 2012)

Governor Jay Nixon spoke at Missouri Boys State on the campus of the University of Central Missouri in Warrensburg on Sunday, June 17, 2012. We were there. We heard his speech and the question and answer session that followed. We recorded it.

In today’s St. Louis Post-Dispatch:

Nixon: Health care stance explained at Boys State

JEFFERSON CITY • Gov. Jay Nixon has responded to Republican criticism that his position on the federal health care law has been murky, at best.

But his response still leaves some unanswered questions….

….Nixon’s office followed up by distributing audio of Nixon’s question-and-answer session with youths attending Boys State in Warrensburg — an event that took place earlier this month….

Governor Jay Nixon (D) at Missouri Boys State on the campus of the University of Central Missouri in Warrensburg on June 17, 2012.

And yes, we caught the exchange. We didn’t transcribe it at the time. So, late, here it is:

….Question: […] In your support of Obamacare what outlook do you have for health care professionals [crosstalk]…

Governor Jay Nixon: My support of what?

Question: Obamacare.

Governor Nixon: Where’d you, what, what, what, what kind of fact based? [voices: “Woo.”] I mean, where’d you get that, I, that I support that?

Question: I just assumed you were a Democrat, so. [voices: “Whoa.”]

Governor Nixon: You know, I, it, uh, I lost to a guy in the, in, in tennis from Chillicothe so I’ll assume you’re a good tennis player, too, you know. [laughter]

Um, the, uh, I don’t think that, I don’t think you should have, uh, uh, a, uh, I don’t think you should have the federal law that orders people that they have to buy insurance. I never have supported that. Uh, you know [applause], I, I, [cheers]. So, I’ll give you a second shot. Go ahead, fire away. [laughter]

Question: Okay, so what is your opinion of Obamacare and what do you think the outlook of it will have for health care officials? [crosstalk][inaudible]

Governor Nixon:  Yeah, I do think it’s, I think it comp, I think there’s a couple things. The short run it’s had some, some, some, some, some challenging effects. I mean, I think people’ve kind of frozen up, they’re not sure what’s gonna happen. And when you get, you know, o, a quarter of your economy waiting, you know, to, to, what to do next, what are the rules gonna be, I think, I think it slugs things, that slows things down. I think that’s, I think once the Supreme Court rules that, that, I think then some decisions can begin to be made.

Um, uh, clearly I think that, that some of the insurance reforms are important and needed. I think that ya, parents should have the option to con, to, to have kids on their policies much older. I don’t think you should be able to, just because you get sick an insurance company should say, [unintelligible] now it cost a hundred thousand or two or three hundred thousand we’re cutting off your insurance. I don’t think you should be able to say, uh, that, that you’re just gonna say, if you get cancer that you’re poor the rest of your life, there’s no, even if you pay for insurance for ten or fifteen or twenty years. I think there’s some really solid insurance reforms in there that are important. But I just think the states are much better positioned, because we’re much more, um, close, uh, in as far as what health care needs to be expanded. I think every kid needs to be covered. I mean, I, I, I think that, that, that, that, that while I’m interested in, kids, to say, ’cause this year I had a big fight with the legislature as they tried to cut blind health care. I mean, my golly. Um, you know, it, it’s, so, I think that kids and, and disabled folks, uh, ex, the expansions that, that’ll help them, uh, are important. Uh, I think some of the stuff that, that, that messes with the market, uh, and, and drives too much on the government side is problematic. I wish they had go, had, had gotten rid of a, a prohibition that we currently have as states that makes it impossible for us to bid, for example, for drugs, uh, you know the quantities of drugs. So, I think that, that, uh, uh, I’m not sure what the Supreme Court will do, uh, but it’ll good to get that done and us then get back to what we’re doing before, which is running these programs from the state level, uh, with, with some federal dollars coming in. But I think this, this, uh, uh. I, I think that that level of sweeping reform and, and the, and the, the constitutional principle of saying that the federal government can pass a law saying you have to buy something, I just, maybe it’s just because I’m from Missouri, but I, I don’t, I don’t like that, they, they haven’t done that before. I, I, you know, I, I think we live in a, in a, uh, in a society that should be much more, much more free. And I understand economically why, if you’re gonna sit there theoretically and say you ought to do it that, that, that folks would, would do it. But I just have never supported that. [inaudible][applause]…

“…But I just think the states are much better positioned, because we’re much more, um, close, uh, in as far as what health care needs to be expanded…”

“…this year I had a big fight with the legislature as they tried to cut blind health care. I mean, my golly…”

Game, set, match. If you don’t see the incompatibility of those two statements I’ll spell it out for you. If we have federal health care reform the Missouri General Assembly won’t be able to cut health insurance for blind people. Instead they’ll be better able to use their time erecting bronze busts of right wingnut radio jocks.

As we hear in some Democratic Party circles: “Jay Nixon is the best republican governor we’ve ever had.”

Also previously:

Missouri Boys State 2012 (June 16, 2012)

Attorney General Chris Koster at Missouri Boys State 2012 – Q and A (June 17, 2012)

Governor Jay Nixon (D) and Kansas City Mayor Sly James at Missouri Boys State 2012 (June 18, 2012)

Kansas City Mayor Sly James at Missouri Boys State 2012 (June 18, 2012)

James Carville at Missouri Boys State 2012 – photos (June 19, 2012)

James Carville at Missouri Boys State 2012 (June 19, 2012)

The Greater Kansas City AFL-CIO on HB 749

22 Friday Jun 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

2012, AFL-CIO, HB 749, health care, Jay Nixon, labor, missouri

Organized labor has a thing or to to say to Governor Jay Nixon in support of a veto of HB 749:

The Greater Kansas City AFL-CIO is urging Governor Nixon to veto Senate Bill 749,

an attack on the rights of American workers.

Organized labor has struggled to extend and maintain workers’ rights, by fighting against many intrusive forms of legislation. One such piece of legislation, S.B. 749 is a violation of every American’s right to decide their health care. It gives employers the unchecked ability to force their own religious beliefs upon their employees. America was built on the idea that people can go to different places on Sunday, but come together on Monday. This principle has given us the freest and most productive economy in the world. Under S.B. 749, employees must check their religious freedom at the workplace door, and take their bosses’ religious beliefs home at the end of the day.

Passing this piece of legislation has seriously negative implications, which will lower the quality of life for Missouri. An employer who manages thousands of workers may refuse to cover the basic, sensible procedures, even when most or all of the employees’ religious views permit these procedures. An employer can impose one religion on all employees. This logic taken to extreme would allow employers to restrict any medical procedure. For instance, it is against the beliefs of Jehovah’s Witnesses to accept blood transfusions, and it is against the beliefs of the Church of Christ, Scientists to seek out any medical professional, using prayer as their only medicine. How would you like to have your boss tell you that they only provide prayers for your child in that case of serious illness or injury?

S.B. 749 also poses an internal conflict with other dumb legislation. For instance, House Bill 708 (anti-Sharia law) proposed this past session, would ban the application of any foreign law that does not provide identical protections to domestic law. S.B. 749 now provides governmental protection to foreign religious law in Missouri workplaces. This is not the direction we should be headed, and vetoing S.B. 749 is the only feasible solution. After all, neither the Catholic catechism nor Muslim sharia was created on American soil.

Using an employer’s religious convictions as a lens to establish health care coverage for employees is unquestionably dangerous, and illegal.  Once started on this path to restrict reproductive coverage, we will see an upsurge of employers using this law against medical coverage of any kind for their employees. Regardless of your personal beliefs about the issue of contraception and abortion, it comes down to protecting workers’ rights in our workplaces. What is done with the coverage thereafter is to each their own personal decision, but to be able to make that decision is strictly an American right. This bill is a wolf in sheep’s clothing. It threatens the religious freedoms of every Missouri employee. We urge the Governor to veto S.B. 749.

Sincerely,

Patrick A. Dujakovich

President, Greater Kansas City AFL-CIO

Yes, there’s a certain lack of ironic awareness when the republican majority in the General Assembly uses government to impose one individual’s religious belief system on others. Nah, with them it’s a feature, not a bug.

Why Kurt Bahr wants to criminalize Obamacare

23 Monday Apr 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

ACA, ALEC, health care, Kurt Bahr, missouri, nullification, Obamacare, tenthers

In 2010 about 20% of eligible Missouri voters went to the polls. Not surprisingly, a majority of that 20% were the foaming at the mouth Tea Partiers and other like-minded souls who were all riled up by anti-Obamacare agit-prop of organizations like Freedom Works and Americans for Prosperity (not to mention the simple fact of the first black president). One of the results of that election was that a crop of impenetrably hard-right pols were introduced into the Missouri legislature.

As a result, the real work of government has been left to patronage groups like the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), which supply anti-union, anti-education, anti-environmental “model” legislation that best serves their anti-worker, anti-tax, corporate purposes. Since such corporate groups are so willing to do the hard work for them, the junior Representatives have been free to ride their favorite hobby horses into the legislative arena. Most recently we’ve seen bills to combat the non-existent threat of Sharia law and bills that the promote hard-currency schemes of paranoid gold-bugs – oh, and don’t forget the bill that would allow bullies to torment gay classmates with impunity.  

Now State Rep. Kurt Bahr (R-19) has married the desire to carry water for the corporatocracy with the 10th amendment fetishism of many of those on the right-wing fringe. Well in advance of the Supreme Court’s decision about the constitutionality of Obamacare, this former intern of U.S. Rep. Todd Akin (R-2) (says it all, doesn’t it?) has introduced HB1534 which asserts that if anybody in Missouri tries to implement the Affordable Care Act (ACA, or Obamacare), they will be subject to criminal charges. Bob Priddy at the MissouriNet Blog sums up Bahr’s position:

So let’s see if we understand Rep. Bahr. He has sworn to uphold the Constitution of the United States. The Constitution of the United States says there are three separate and co-equal branches of government, legislative, executive, and judicial. Rep. Bahr argues that a legislature in one of the 50 states can make a judicial ruling as it affects only the people of that state. (The PP&ACA is so unconstitutional that anyone implementing any part of it is a criminal.) It appears he should start getting ready to issue warrants because some parts of the Affordable Healthcare Act already are being implemented in Missouri.

Wouldn’t you know that, first-time around, the rampaging GOP nullifiers in the House passed this piece of idiocy 109-41. Details of the debate, including some very amusing audio, can be heard here. It’s worth reading (and listening to); Rep. Chris Kelly aptly sums up the Democrats’ frustration with Bahr’s thick-headed embrace of nullification, declaring that “this is breathtaking in its contempt for the Constitution of the United States.”

Bahr’s last (first? middling?) stand also works well with the goals of the mostly anonymous corporate types who finance organizations like ALEC. Ed Quillen of the Denver Post has argued that the rabid anti-Obamacare frothing of politicians like Bahr is just another facet of the attack on workers that the corporate elite is waging through their GOP proxies. Writing about why the GOP is doing little to actually promote job creation, but lots to benefit “job-creators,” he states that Republicans aren’t just stepping on the brakes because they want our Democratic president to fail:

When it comes to jobs, there’s more to the story than the normal political desire to defeat someone of the other party. Republicans like employers, those noble “job-creators” vexed by bureaucracy and regulation. They don’t like workers.

If jobs are hard to come by, then employers have more power, just as it’s a lot easier to say “take this job and shove it” if you know they’re hiring down the street. That’s another reason Republicans want to keep unemployment high.

This also helps explain the Republican resistance to universal health care. If you must rely on your employer for health insurance, that helps keep you in your place, and your employer literally has power of life and death over you.

Bahr’s spite-fueled legislative tantrum directed at the ACA may be feel-good medicine for those who are inclined to constitutional posturing, but it is also intended to insure that it is the unfettered market – that is to say, employers, and ultimately, the corporatocracy – that will have the ultimate power over our lives. Quillen correctly observes that the model that the right embraces is that of the Deep South where the Republican “oligarchs”:

… want “a compliant, poorly educated, low-wage workforce with as few labor, workplace safety, health care, and environmental regulations as possible.

Dare I mention that, when it comes to the legislative crop of 2010 we get a do-over this November?

 

Today's Obamacare factoid especially for Missourians.

31 Saturday Mar 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

ACA, Affordable Care Act, health care, missouri, Obamacare

FuseWashington.org notes that many states – at least 38 states, in fact – permit insurance companies to discriminate in pricing health care based on gender. The site offers (h/t DailyKos) a nifty little chart that shows how much more than men women in each of the 50 states pay now pay. Here in Missouri the figure is 25-50% more.

The chart also shows that after Obamacare is fully phased in in 2014, women will pay no more or no less than men – because such discrimination will be prohibited by the law of the land.

Of course that depends on whether or not the Bush appointees (both Bushes – remember who nominated Thomas) on the Supreme Court decide to go on a repeal-the-new-deal bender.  

Claire McCaskill, commies, liberals, centrists and Obamacare

08 Thursday Mar 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Claire McCaskill, health care, Mediare, missouri, Obamacare, Ryancare

So Rush Limbaugh thinks our Missouri Senator Claire McCaskill is a “commie babe liberal“? Lordy! Sure fooled me. I can’t speak to the “babe” epithet, but nobody’s really a “commie” nowadays. It’s passé. McCaskill might be mildly liberal, although I think that she’s been pretty careful to try to hew to the right-of-center line with only tiny detours leftwards now and then. If labels were strictly a function of policy positions, I suppose I’d be inclined to describe her as similar to that old standby, the “Rockefeller Republican” with a little feminist leavening. But these days, of course, we Democrats make do with what we can get.

To make that point even clearer, McCaskill proved that it takes a centrist to know a centrist policy when she pointed out that Obamacare is a mild-mannered and moderate plan that lines up with many GOP preferences. In McCaskill’s words it is Ryancare for the non-elderly:

“The irony of this situation is that these are private insurance companies people will shop to buy their insurance. It’s not the government,” she told KMOX of St. Louis on Wednesday. “It’s exactly what Paul Ryan wants to do for Medicare.”

TPM explains the seeming GOP cognitive dissonance about Obamacare in terms of the underlying agendas of progressives and conservatives:

McCaskill’s point is an important one that exposes the real nature of the underlying fight over how to fix health care. The progressive ideal is a single payer system, a la Medicare, but for everyone. The conservative ideal is a deregulated market-based system with a diminished federal role. The Affordable Care Act, despite the right’s protestations of socialism, is a middle ground between the two. And the insurance exchanges mirror what the Ryan plan does to Medicare – as Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) and Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) have conceded.

These awkward admissions reveal that the broader fight is really about which direction to move vis-a-vis national health policy. Conservatives hate Obamacare because, by setting up regulated, subsidized exchanges for the public at large, it moves the existing system away from their goal of rolling back federal health care programs. Liberals hate Ryancare because, by replacing Medicare with a subsidized private insurance market, it constitutes a leap backwards from the current state of affairs.

As TPM’s Sahil Kapur implies above, no matter how big a backwards step Ryancare might represent, Obamacare still constitutes a mighty step forward for American health care overall given the nature of the previous status quo. It represents a necessary compromise in light of the rightward drift of American politics over the past couple of decades, which has created an environment in which a middle-aged, middling moderate pol can be described by a nasty-mouthed shock-jock as a “commie liberal babe.”

 

Campaign Finance: Is anyone surprised?

20 Monday Feb 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

campaign finance, health care, missouri, Missouri Ethics Commission

Today, at the Missouri Ethics Commission:

C000953 02/20/2012 MO REPUBLICAN PARTY RightChoice Managed Care, Inc. PO Box 68086 Cincinnati OH 45206 2/20/2012 $25,000.00

[emphasis added]

From 2011 (contributions over $5,000.00):

C000653 02/23/2011 MO INSURANCE COALITION PAC RightCHOICE Managed Care, Inc. PO Box 68086 Cincinnati OH 45206 2/23/2011 $10,000.00

C061138 04/26/2011 LEWIS & CLARK REGIONAL LEADERSHIP FUND RightCHOICE Managed Care, Inc. P.O. BOX 68086 Cincinnati OH 45206 4/26/2011 $12,000.00

C031160 06/23/2011 FRIENDS OF TILLEY RIGHTCHOICE MANAGED CARE INC PO BOX 68086 CINCINNATI OH 45206 6/22/2011 $12,500.00

C091248 06/28/2011 FRIENDS OF CALEB JONES RightCHOICE Managed Care, Inc. PO Box 68086 Cincinnati OH 45206 6/28/2011 $10,000.00

C051087 06/30/2011 CITIZENS FOR TIMOTHY W JONES RightCHOICE Managed Care Inc. Post Office Box 68086 Cinncinatti OH 45206 6/30/2011 $11,500.00

C061726 07/09/2011 DEMPSEY FOR SENATE RightChoice Managed Care Inc PO Box 68086 Cincinnati OH 45206 7/8/2011 $10,000.00

C071116 07/20/2011 FRIENDS OF CHRIS MOLENDORP RightCHOICE Managed Care, Inc. PO Box 68086 Cincinnati OH 45206 7/18/2011 $10,000.00

C031160 07/21/2011 FRIENDS OF TILLEY RightChoice Managed Care, Inc. PO Box 68086 Cincinnati OH 45206 7/21/2011 $12,500.00

C091068 07/28/2011 HOUSE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE INC RightChoice Managed Care Inc PO Box 68086 Cinncinnati OH 45206 7/28/2011 $12,500.00

C071320 08/04/2011 SCHMITT FOR SENATE RightChoice Managed Care Inc PO Box 68086 Cincinnati OH 45206 8/4/2011 $10,000.00

[emphasis added]

Let’s look at that list:

C091248: Friends Of Caleb Jones

Po Box 5 Committee Type: Candidate

California Mo 65018 Party Affiliation: Republican

(573) 424-7452 Established Date: 10/09/2009

[emphasis added]

C051087: Citizens For Timothy W Jones

Po Box 434 Committee Type: Candidate

Eureka Mo 63025 Party Affiliation: Republican

(314) 229-0338 Established Date: 04/01/2005

[emphasis added]

C031160: Friends Of Tilley

718 Big Spring Blvd Committee Type: Candidate

Perryville Mo 63775 Party Affiliation: Republican

(573) 768-1530 Established Date: 08/19/2003

[emphasis added]

C061726: Dempsey For Senate

Two Westbury Drive Committee Type: Candidate

St Charles Mo 63301 Party Affiliation: Republican

(636) 946-2800 Established Date: 12/29/2006

[emphasis added]

C071116: Friends Of Chris Molendorp

Po Box 722 Committee Type: Candidate

Belton Mo 64012 Party Affiliation: Republican

(816) 331-9335 Established Date: 05/25/2007

[emphasis added]

C071320: Schmitt For Senate

Po Box 220722 Committee Type: Candidate

Kirkwood Mo 63122-0022 Party Affiliation: Republican

(314) 822-3808 Established Date: 10/12/2007

[emphasis added]

Why would that be?

What will Obamacare do for Missourians in 2014?

15 Wednesday Feb 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

ACA, Affordable Care Act, health care, Jane Cunningham, missouri, Obamacare, uninsured

Those who have been paying attention to facts rather than GOP rhetoric know that the Affordable Care Act (ACA), a.k.a. Obamacare, has already had a positive impact in a number of areas such as permitting parents to keep their young adult children on their existing insurance policies until they are 26, providing  affordable coverage for those with pre-existing conditions, and strengthening existing and creating new community health centers (which also, incidentally, adds jobs). The primary goal of Obamacare, however, is to  extend insurance to uninsured Americans. As the Kaiser Foundation notes, starting in 2014, it will do so in two ways:

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) includes two primary mechanisms for helping people afford health coverage. Starting in 2014, people with family incomes up to 138% of the poverty level ($31,809 for a family of four and $15,415 for a single person in 2012) will generally be eligible for the Medicaid program. And, people buying coverage on their own in new state-based health insurance exchanges will be eligible for federal tax credits to subsidize the cost of insurance. Tax credits will be calculated on a sliding scale basis for people with family income up to four times the poverty level ($92,200 for a family of four and $44,680 for a single person in 2012). …

The map below, from a new Kaiser Foundation report, shows the geographic distribution of the nonelderly Americans who stand to benefit from these twin programs:

Using the accompanying zip code based calculator provided by the Kaiser Foundation, one finds that in Poplar Bluff, Missouri 26% of the nonelderly population could benefit from these ACA programs; 20% are eligible for these programs in the Central Missouri area around Columbia. In my own relatively prosperous West St. Louis County zip code, 63011, from 8%-10% of the nonelderly population will benefit from either the Medicaid expansion or subsidized coverage available through the health care exchanges in 2014. Looks like the ACA stands to meet some serious need in much of Missouri, especially, as the map suggests, in extreme Southeastern, Northeastern and pockets in Southwestern Missouri.

Meanwhile, in the state Senate, a few die-hard anti-Obamacare zealots, like, for example, my own Senator Jane Cunningham (R-7), are standing in the way of the work that is needed to establish the insurance exchanges that the ACA mandates as the mechanism to provide low-cost, federally-regulated insurance to those who need it. They’ve stormed, raged and lied themselves blue in the face about what the ACA will do, and now they’re stalling, hoping against hope that the Supreme Court will uphold their extremist reading of the Constitution.

Bear in mind that if our intransigent lawmakers continue to stall and their trust in conservative judicial activism is not fulfilled, Missouri will not be prepared to submit a plan for an exchange by Jan. 1, 2013 – which means that the federal government will step in do the work that the state refuses to do. Given the general level of functioning that I see in Missouri governmental circles, that doesn’t seem like too much of a problem to me, but I do seem to remember that these folks are the very ones who constantly whine that the federal government can’t deal effectively with local needs.  As the News-Leader points out:

We already have a $20.8 million federal grant for the exchange. It’s not a question of money. It’s a question of political will. The Missouri House passed legislation moving the state-based exchange forward. The Missouri Senate should do the same. And Gov. Jay Nixon should be stepping out front to lead on this important issue.

Hear! Hear!

Funding contraception and freedom of conscience: Another manufactured controversy

08 Wednesday Feb 2012

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ 3 Comments

Tags

Archbishop Robert Carlson, birth control, Catholic Church, contraception, health care, missouri, pastoral letter, Scott Rupp

Via a pastoral letter, Archbishop Robert Carlson has formally added his name to the roster of American Catholic heavyweights who oppose the Obama administration’s new rule that would widen access to contraception. He claims he is doing so in the name of “rights of conscience.” The Missouri legislature is also jumping into the fray because “religious groups should not have to pay for birth control or abortions for their employees if that would violate their beliefs.” Specifically, GOP Senator Scott Rupp “introduced a measure Tuesday to amend the state’s constitution and forbid state laws or rules that force an individual, employer or health care provider to cover the costs of birth control or abortions.”

All this gum-flapping on the topic of “conscience” and “religious freedom” leaves me with few questions and observations:

— Does this rule force anyone to buy or use contraception?  

— Does this rule force any specifically religious organization staffed by members of the church in question to field health care plans that cover contraception?

— Does anything in the new rule, Senator Rupp, mention abortion or even drugs such as the morning after pill (RU486)?

— Are any insurance providers required to provide coverage for contraception?

The answer in all cases is emphatically no.

The new rule does, though, require that contraceptives be included in insurance plans offered by religiously-affiliated organizations with a non-religious mission that employ individuals who are not necessarily members of the affiliated churches. If such organizations do not comply, they stand to forfeit federal funds or tax credits. The argument offered by the Archbishop and by Senator Rupp is that, by offering such a health care plan, the church in question is being forced to indirectly subsidize (horror of horrors) contraception. That this reasoning is, at the very least, questionable is obvious when one considers a number of questions that it gives rise to:

— Don’t many of these religiously affiliated organizations derive income from public payments for services they render, or from the federal government? So why are the churches carrying on like they bear the brunt of paying for the health care these institutions provide their employees and, in the case of colleges and universities, students.

— The whole issue of indirect culpability is problematic. For instance, if a religiously affiliated hospital were to have saved the life of Hitler – knowing that he was was in the process of instituting the final solution – is the affiliated church indirectly responsible for Hitler’s crimes? If so, should the doctors have let Hitler die? Or, perhaps, even hasten his death? You can, doubtless come up with numerous parallel if less extreme examples. (I only mention Hitler because already some right-wing fools have predictably started comparing the new rule to the rise of the German Nazis. We can all play at rhetorical overkill.)

— How expansive should arguments about rights of conscience be? What about a religious businessman who thinks contraception is the devil’s tool and  wants his business to be granted the same religious exemption the churches are demanding in order to curtail his female employees’ access to birth control?

— To narrow the frame of reference of the question above, why are some religions and religious issues privileged over others? As Katha Politt puts it in regard to Catholic opposition:

Are Quakers, Jehovah’s Witnesses and other pacifists exempt from taxes that pay for war and weapons? Can Scientologists, who abhor psychiatry, deduct the costs of the National Institute of Mental Health?

— Should conscience rights take precedence over public welfare? Certainly, the courts don’t always think so. Consider, for instance, the Supreme Court decision that found polygamy illegal because it was successfully argued not to be in society’s interests.  

— What about the right of non-believing employees to be free from religiously motivated interference in their personal lives, “freedom from religion” if you will, which is arguably implicit in the construct “freedom of religion”?  Senator Rupp and the Archbishop would, presumably, answer that such individuals are free not to seek employment at religiously affiliated institutions. In a time of massive unemployment, most of us can readily see that this response is both callous and unrealistic, and, even from the point of view of the institutions in question, would lead to undesirable consequences.

Actually, to get an idea about why this argument fails, just turn the tables. If the issue is really one of conscience, aren’t religiously affiliated organizations free to give up the federal funds that are tied to their compliance with the rule? No fuss, no bother. One could even argue that it hardly behooves tax-exempt organizations like churches to take taxpayer dollars in the first place. Conscience does not operate in a vacuum.

— To take the question of rights one step further yet, what about the conscience rights of women to plan their families for the benefit of their children? Why should Archbishop Carlson’s Catholic conscience rights have more standing than that of an agnostic nurse in a Catholic hospital?

— If the issue is so pressing that the august leaders of the Catholic Church and GOP lawmakers have to leap in wearing their heavy stomping boots, why have religiously affiliated organizations, such as, for instance, Depaul University, Boston College and Caritas Christi Catholic hospitals in Massachusetts, been willing to offer their employees, without handwringing and undue melodrama, insurance plans that cover contraception? Several states, in fact, have enacted similar mandates:

Over half of Americans already live in the 28 states that require insurance companies cover contraception: Several of these states like North Carolina, New York, and California have identical religious employer exemptions. Some states like Colorado, Georgia and Wisconsin have no exemption at all.

— Finally, could there be hidden agendas on the part of folks like the Archbishop and Senator Rupp?

In the context of the Archbishop’s righteouos indignation, I’ll point out that according to a recent poll, conducted by the Public Religion Research Institute, 58% of Catholics support requirements that Catholic affiliated colleges, hospitals and charities offer access to birth control in their insurance plans. It is well-known that many, if not most, Catholics use birth control – 98% according to the Guttmacher Institute. If Church leaders like Archbishop Carlson cannot control their wayward flocks, why should the U.S. government be subborned into doing so via state edict?

As for Senator Rupp, maybe he smells an opportunity to make trouble for the opposition while reaping some pander points. He can ga
rner credit with sex-obsessed zealots by opposing contraception, and he can do it by making ostensibly high-minded claims about “freedom of conscience.” He has to know that the claims are weak; why else would he evoke abortion – a non-issue in the new rules, but a guaranteed alarm bell to the aforesaid zealots?

No matter how you slice it, the  self-congratulatory, high-minded dudgeon of the anti-birth control crowd ignores the welfare of real people while limiting the right of all women, all individuals actually, to make their own health choices in private.  I wouldn’t want to ask my boss if I could use birth control and I don’t think you should have to do so either.  

We know the answer

17 Saturday Sep 2011

Posted by Michael Bersin in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

2012, health care, republicans

From MoveOn:

Wolf Blitzer: But congressman, are you saying that society should just let him die?

[voice: “Yeah”]

Congressman Ron Paul (r): No…

[voice: “Yeah”]

Susan Grigsby: What really horrified me about that debate wasn’t the, the poorly phrased question. It wasn’t Dr. Paul’s answer. And it wasn’t even the scream after Wolf Blitzer asked would you let him die and somebody in the audience yelled, yeah. That wasn’t as horrifying as was the silence from the stage from these men and women who are running for office. Not a word. Nothing. I was horrified.

That’s when I started thinking about Steve. As an adult he worked full time all the time. And when he was fifty-five he was replaced by a young man and he had to start looking for a job. At fifty-five years old, you know, you can kiss that good bye. He looked for a job, he looked for a job.

My brother Steve at sixty-three, and unemployed and uninsured was too young for Medicare and he was too male for Medicaid.

The spot was found on Steve’s lung on December third of twenty-ten. Within five months he had gone through radiation, he’d gone through some therapy, he had been warehoused, he slowly, painfully, he couldn’t stand up, the cancer went into his nerves and his spine. Five months later he died. That’s what it means to let someone die.

[What would you ask the GOP nominees if you could?]        

Do you, as a candidate for president, really believe that if an American cannot get or does not get insurance that they should be treated the way Steve was? Do you really believe that?  

[Dear GOP candidates: Answer the question.]

That was my brother’s death you were cheering, you a$$holes (September 13, 2011)

← Older posts
Newer posts →

Recent Posts

  • Eric Schmitt (r): Now for the rest of the story….
  • Quinton Lucas (D): Exploratory Committee – Governor in 2028
  • Josh Hawley (r): just another ladder to climb…
  • Johnson County Democrats – Celebrating the Blue Tsunami – Warrensburg, Missouri – November 19, 2026
  • Mark Alford (r): downward spiral toward irrelevance

Recent Comments

Steve Duane Phipps on Johnson County Democrats…
Eric Schmitt (r): fl… on Eric Schmitt (r): maybe nobody…
Education: showing u… on A lack of imagination…
Eric Schmitt (r): ma… on Eric Schmitt (r): “somet…
Eric Schmitt (r):… on Perfect timing

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • November 2025
  • October 2025
  • September 2025
  • August 2025
  • July 2025
  • June 2025
  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • March 2025
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • June 2024
  • May 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • July 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • July 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011
  • June 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
  • December 2010
  • November 2010
  • October 2010
  • September 2010
  • August 2010
  • July 2010
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • June 2009
  • May 2009
  • April 2009
  • March 2009
  • February 2009
  • January 2009
  • December 2008
  • November 2008
  • October 2008
  • September 2008
  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • May 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • December 2007
  • November 2007
  • October 2007
  • September 2007
  • August 2007

Categories

  • campaign finance
  • Claire McCaskill
  • Congress
  • Democratic Party News
  • Eric Schmitt
  • Healthcare
  • Hillary Clinton
  • Interview
  • Jason Smith
  • Josh Hawley
  • Mark Alford
  • media criticism
  • meta
  • Missouri General Assembly
  • Missouri Governor
  • Missouri House
  • Missouri Senate
  • Resist
  • Roy Blunt
  • social media
  • Standing Rock
  • Town Hall
  • Uncategorized
  • US Senate

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Blogroll

  • Balloon Juice
  • Crooks and Liars
  • Digby
  • I Spy With My Little Eye
  • Lawyers, Guns, and Money
  • No More Mister Nice Blog
  • The Great Orange Satan
  • Washington Monthly
  • Yael Abouhalkah

Donate to Show Me Progress via PayPal

Your modest support helps keep the lights on. Click on the button:

Blog Stats

  • 1,107,116 hits

Powered by WordPress.com.

Loading Comments...